Showing posts with label the social network. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the social network. Show all posts

Saturday, October 10, 2026

Catholiccontrivery's The Social Reconning Review

*Sigh* well that was complete revisionist history. Hello catholiccontrivery here, and when I saw that there was going to be a movie about the 2021 Facebook Files news story I was pretty excited, especially when the trailers highlighted how powerful Facebook had become, and how they were more powerful than national governments. Now I admittedly didn't follow the coverage very closely, but I remember it basically validating everything I've suspected about facebook being evil ever since like 2008. Basically the story was all about how facebook was knowingly causing harm to it's users through over use and negative imagery, causing body dysmorphia in teens and addiction in the general userbase, collecting an unimaginable amount of data on it's users without any transparency about how that data was being used and where they were getting it from, and how they were putting their thumbs on the scales of elections boosting stories favorable to the left and suppressing stories favorable to the right (particularly the Hunter Biden laptop story that would have changed the 2020 election), with it all coming to how they were arguably acting as a publisher while operating under section 230 common carrier protections. It also highlighted how much of a lizard person Mark Zuckerberg is when he had to testify in front of congress. This movie though, well it was highly inaccurate.

First though, I have to give credit where it's due. On a technical level, this movie is pretty good. The acting is really good, especially the parts with Mark Zuckerberg. Unlike this directors first attempt at telling a facebook story (which I reviewed 15 years ago, WOW), Mark doesn't talk at double the speed, and he REALLY captured the lizard person aspect of Mark from the congressional hearings. Francis and Jeff are also really good (even if I just see Max from Better Things and Carmy from The Bear), I really could see them as a Facebook engineer and investigative reporter, with very believable emotions and actions. Bill Burr's character also was great, an early investor who knew Mark from the beginning and is the only one to can talk frankly to him, yeah totally believable and I could definitely see his Charlie character being a real person. The directing is also quite good, especially with how it relates to the pacing and editing (for the most part, the opening scene is a little sloppy, but that might have been on purpose). One thing this movie does is go back and forth between Mark preparing for the congressional hearing and the progression of events in the breaking of the story, and the way it cuts between scenes and shots is pretty good on a technical level. It also divides the story up into chapters, which is can come off as tacky or pretentious, but it worked in this movie, so I'll give it that. There's also some good laugh out loud moments, where I did audibly laugh. I'm pretty sure it was meant to be comic relief, but if not, happy accident.

I also want to briefly talk about the rating. The movie is rated R, but it's not a very strong R, I'd argue that it's pretty soft. The general rule is that you can only say "f---" once in a PG-13 movie, and if you say it any more times you get an R rating. I wasn't exactly keeping track, but I think this movie says it like 5 or 6 times, which is more than once. There's also "the riot at the end of the movie" (which I will go into more detail in due time), where you see people with bleeding heads from cuts and similar, but it's nothing worse that what you'd see in pro-wrestling. Quinton Tarantino or Robert Rodrigues, this is not. There's also a short scene where it's "explicitly implied" that a character was about to have sex, but they're both still covered up; the man still has pants on and the woman still has "skimpy gym attire" (meant to be underwear, but it covered even more than a normal bra and brief cut panties), you see worse on network TV. When I noticed it was rated R I thought "I wonder what kind of gratuitous Oppenheimer sex scenes we'll get," but there weren't any. When this inevitably airs on TV with a TV-14 rating, basically all they're going to have to do is mute the f-bombs and not change anything else.

[Spoiler warning]

OK, it's about time that I get into why this movie is revisionist fiction. Instead of focusing on...anything I mentioned in my opening paragraph about the actual news stories and studies, the movie primarily focused on how Facebook was "sending people down the alt-right pipeline" and how they "weren't doing enough to police posts," with only 2 very brief mentions about how facebook and its subsidiaries were harming teens; once in a restaurant scene where a girl was getting bullied online and the bullies were using facebook groups as a loophole around the bullying rules, and another when one of the other employees said "here's a classified internal study where we found the harm instagram is doing to teen girls," and then there were some casual mentions about how drug traffickers and human traffickers were operating in the open and some other things of that nature, but they didn't get any kind of attention. Everything else in this movie was about how facebook was pushing an algorithm that was leading people into "hate groups" (becoming right wing), and "allowing people to spread misinformation, particularly about covid and the 2020 election," with emphasis on not fact checking political ads, with Mark's excuse being that "Facebook and its subsidiaries are open platforms, and Mark Zuckerberg is a free speech absolutist since Facebook is the town square and to do so otherwise would be to violate section 230 since now they would be acting as a publisher." *deep breath in...and breath out.* What fantasy world are you living in? Facebook is/was allowing people to spread right wing misinformation? Facebook was suppressing right wing users during this time, Steven Crowder did an experiment with that and found that he was being suppressed. Other conservative users did the same thing, "facebook jail (temporary suspension) for telling the truth" was a super common thing back then. Everyone on the left was saying "well if you don't like it then go build your own facebook," which is why places like minds and meewee were made. "Mark is a free speech absolutist," yeah and next you'll be telling me Kim Jon Un has a sense of humor and can laugh at himself. "Facebook allowed users to spread vaccine misinformation and falsehoods about the novel virus," *ppppppttttthhhhh raspberry* Facebook was taking down practicing doctors saying "masks aren't doing anything, quote the CDC, for young people this is no more dangerous than the flu." Let's also not forget the Hunter Biden laptop story, a news story that FACEBOOK BLOCKED PEOPLE FROM SHARING THE LINK TO "because it was misinformation, fake news, propaganda" (that was confirmed to be true after the election where analysts agree that if it was allowed to be shared it would have changed the results of the 2020 election). But yeah, keep telling yourself that Mark Zuckerberg is a free speech absolutist.

The end is what REALLY angered me. The end of this movie is about January 6th 2021, specifically Facebook's response to it. What it shows is a mob congregating at the capital and it being spread all over Facebook. They also said "is he [president Trump] saying anything" and "no." Then they showed a very violent mob, with the rioters smashing windows, trampling police officers, and bashing them in the head, with capital police being carried into a room on makeshift stretchers made of the barricade fence. And then when they banned "the president" it was depicted as being some super hard decision. That was just straight up lies and bull. First off, president Trump said "peacefully and patriotically let your voices be known," AND told people "stop, go home, don't cause a riot." That was just straight up lies. Also, that was not what the day was. Once the videos were declassified, it was a walking tour; some people got a little carried away, but it was not the antifa or BLM riot that the media pretends it was. Lastly, there's no way that Facebook thought it was some "hard decision," they were salivating at the prospect at banning President Trump, but they couldn't because of how bad it would look if they deplatformed a sitting president.

Just a terrible movie, nothing but lies and propaganda. I didn't really have anywhere to put this before, but another thing this movie did was try to say that new media replacing legacy media was a bad thing "because there's no credentials, no vetting, people just report whatever they want." Right, because people gatekeeping information is a good thing, because those gate keepers will report on vital information like how Joe Biden had serious cognitive declines, Hunter Biden throwing a gun away at a school, Ashley Biden writing in a diary how her dad would shower with her LONG after it was creepy, Barak Obama telling foreign adversaries "I'll be more flexible after the election," Kamala extending prisoner's sentences because of free labor, Hillary Clinton deleting 30K subpoenaed emails, Gretchen Whitmer sending young covid patients to nursing homes, Somali daycare fraud in Minnesota, Nick Sandman just calmly smiling as a drug addict Native American chanted in his face while trying to slander a high school kid, the violence that is found in the BLM and Antifa riots, and all sorts of other things...oh wait, no they completely buried those stories and instead wanted to run non-stop coverage of how the right was doing trivial things, and the only reason any of these got through was because of new media. And then during the epilogue thing where it said what happened to everyone after the events of the movie, they said something like "in response to not fact checking ads, facebook decided to stop fact checking all together" like it's a bad thing. Oh, you mean the same fact checkers that said it was "mostly false" when asked "the German government made and distributed leaflets to discourage sexual assault after an incident in Cologne New Years Eve 2015-2016," because the leaflets were actually first made in 2013 for something similar and were redistributed because of things. Yeah, no, that was just back handed censorship without censoring. Just, don't watch this movie. This has been catholiccontriversy, signing off, and may God bless you.

Saturday, July 23, 2011

Pokematic Reviews The Social Network

I found this the worst movie ever. Every aspect screamed bad. How this got an Oscar is beyond me. (So people will get a preview of the post with a search engine.)

If it's not a good game or catholic....Who do you call....Why pokematic. Hi.
Search & Win
I just rented the Oscar nominated, or was it awarded film, The social network. The sticker at family video said so. Though I have one question. How did such a terrible movie such as this receive an Oscar and was the most popular film of the year. Or was it nominated. I don't remember and neither IMDB nor Wikipedia will tell me.

So as I was saying, this movie was horrible. Everything about it screamed horrible. The acting, the scripting, the lighting, the overall images, the pacing, EVERYTHING terrible.

Let me start with the storytelling genera. OK, the film tries to be a documentary style film without being a documentary. So to compensate for it's lack of actual documentary, it attempts at being a drama. Here's the issue with blending genres. It doesn't always work as I have pointed out with Unnatural History. Shivers, unnatural history. OK, this blending of genres failed. It would have been better if they had the ability to do an actual documentary with the actual people. But unfortunately they couldn't. So they tried this and failed.

Next lets talk about the Zuckerberg character. While I don't know if he was like this in real life, they made him incredibly distant from being like an actual human. He talks so damn fast I had to replay scenes where he talked so I could here what he said. Now any good director would tell his/her actors to slow down so the audience can understand what the lines are. It is quite frustrating when someone speaks so fast that you can't understand what they're saying and what they are saying is important for the story. I know there is a comedy technique that involves speaking so fast that it is barely comprehend able. But even then they typically say the same sort of thing over and over again many times so the audience can understand what is being said. That was not the case with Zuckerberg. He spoke incredibly fast and said things once. That's not good. You will leave your audience confused as to what was just said.
Another thing about him was the fact that he had absolutely no emotions. And when I say none, I mean none. In addition to the super fast. It was also mono-tone. Any public speaker will tell you that you will bore your audience if you speak mono-toneistically. It was a bore listening to him. And he was put in situations that would lead to a rainbow of emotions. Wow rainbow of emotions. Anyways, it was like listening to a robot. But not a cool one. If that was intended, it sucked.

The story moved way to fast. Well "story" is a bit of a stretch but I'll get to that. We start out with Zuckerberg on a date with some girl that did little for the story. So then it goes really quickly to Zuckerber creating a hot or not site of people from his college. Weird but OK. That site goes viral and he is then thrown into writing "the facebook." (look confused scratching head) Uhhh OK. But in writing the hot or not site he used some chess algorithm. How does that work? But before I could try to figure that out, he's getting sued. What the? Over what? Apparently he stole some kind of algorithm in writing "the facebook." Wait, what algorithm? That one for writing the hot or not site? I was so confused. So at that point I gave up and stopped watching it. Yeah that's right, I stopped a movie before it was over.

I mentioned the "story" earlier, or lack there of. The "story" was so dry that I would rather watch the news. And PS; I hate the news. But I won't get into it. I get that it's about the finding of facebook, but I have not seen a story so dry and boring since reading a history text book. And might I mention that there were elements that added nothing to the story and were shearly random. Example A: the scene where the couple make out in a bathroom stall for about 5 minutes. It's not like it even added sex appeal because there was nothing hot about it. The only reason people think this story was "intriguing" was because it was about their favorite website ever. Oh, and my cousins who are facebook addicts, hated this movie. It was that bad.

Now I mentioned the camera and lighting very early on. Like at the beginning of the post. I read a review that said that the lighting and camera was amazing. Obviously the guy hasn't seen good movies with great lighting and camera. Many of the scenes took place at either night or in dark places. Now for a scene or two, that can be fine. Or if it takes place at night and is like a spy movie or something, playing with different shades of black and shadows takes care of that. But that wasn't the case. Lots of the scenes in the dark had poor lighting causing an ugly yellow to come off as the whites and so. Then all the dark looked horrible against Zuckerbergs white face, causing it to look like a floating head. Then there was the jump to the light scenes, and it was a bit much. It was like "whoah! Color shock." If I were to do something like this and hand it in as a project for video class. My teacher would have given me a bad grade or tell me to redo it because the camera and lighting was horrible.

After all this bashing, I feel I should tell the one thing that was nearly good. I'm a nerd, I know HTML coding. At one point, they were talking about all the math and coding that goes into it. But that was barely any of it. So once the movie almost got my attention. It lost it by dropping the nerd stuff. And loved the shout outs to myspace but we all know he destroyed the fan base for that with his stupid site.

I have absolutely no idea how this movie got such high praise. It dethroned Scott Pilgrim as worst movie I've ever scene. I'll get to that later. That just proves that the Oscars are rigged, because this movie sucked. Don't waist your time on this horrible movie.

Well this has been Pokematic signing off and bu bye.